The High Cost of Big Government—a Heist on Taxpayers

COMMENTARY Budget and Spending

The High Cost of Big Government—a Heist on Taxpayers

May 1, 2025 2 min read

Commentary By

Richard Stern

Acting Director, Roe Institute and Director, Hermann Center

Katherine Miller

Spring 2025 Member of the Young Leaders Program at The Heritage Foundation

No business could survive losing billions without tracking where it went. In Washington, though, failure just demands more taxpayer dollars to bury the mess. Jun / Getty Images

Key Takeaways

In fiscal year 2024, just 16 agencies reported improper payment estimates that totaled $162 billion—money lost to error, fraud, overpayments, or ineligible claims.

Every wasted dollar—like the billions lost to improper payments—adds to a taxpayer burden that’s now over $270,000 per household.

The government isn’t underfunded—it's wastefully stolen too much of what we have all worked hard to produce.

$521 billion. That’s the estimate the federal government itself put forward of annual fraud levels. That’s enough money to rebuild every crumbling bridge and school in the country—all squandered due to government incompetence.

In fiscal year 2024, just 16 agencies reported improper payment estimates that totaled $162 billion—money lost to error, fraud, overpayments, or ineligible claims. That’s part of a staggering $2.8 trillion lost since 2003.

And that’s just what’s been reported. Fraud-heavy programs like Temporary Assistance for Needy Families (TANF) and housing subsidies likely push the total higher.

This isn’t a mere accounting error; it’s a heist on taxpayers, stealing cash that could’ve stayed in your wallet.

Nearly 75% of these losses come from five programs: Medicare, Medicaid, the Earned Income Tax Credit, SNAP, and the Restaurant Revitalization Fund. For these programs, error rates amount roughly to 45%.

>>> The Pentagon’s War on Wasted Dollars

Unemployment insurance (UI) is another major culprit, with its controls collapsing during COVID-19 and fueling fraud through identity theft. Retirees wait for delayed Social Security checks while the government keeps paying benefits to the dead.

All told, that’s billions that could lower health care costs, stabilize Social Security, or shrink the deficit—all lost to the black hole of government dysfunction.

Worse, many federal agencies don’t follow basic accountability laws. In 2023, the Government Accountability Office (GAO) flagged 11 major agencies—including the Department of Defense (DOD), Health and Human Services, and Treasury—for breaking payment integrity laws.

The DOD exemplifies these problems. Despite its massive budget, it’s never passed a clean audit, and its outdated systems and lax fraud controls leave taxpayers footing the bill for untold losses.

Other government agencies skip reporting losses entirely or ignore fraud-reduction crackdowns.

No business could survive losing billions without tracking where it went—they’d go bankrupt overnight. In Washington, though, failure just demands more taxpayer dollars to bury the mess.

The national debt has soared past $35 trillion, with $2 trillion annual deficits piling up. Every wasted dollar—like the billions lost to improper payments—adds to a taxpayer burden that’s now over $270,000 per household.

As the government borrows more to cover these gaps, it floods the market with debt, pushing interest rates above 5%. Debt payments now outstrip defense spending—a fact that drives up mortgage rates, loan costs, and everyday expenses for families and businesses.

>>> The Front Lines of Bureaucratic Bloat: The Labor Market

The GAO’s proposed fixes—stricter reporting, blocking ineligible payments, extending fraud investigations—are a start. But they don’t touch the root problem: Washington’s reckless expansion of government programs. When these programs grow too big, fraud and mismanagement become inevitable.

Some argue cuts harm the needy. But the real damage is the waste, which lets scammers siphon off billions that should reach veterans and retirees. More money won’t solve this problem; accountability will.

Congress must eliminate improper payments, not adjust them.

Agencies squandering taxpayer dollars should face budget cuts and leadership overhaul. Fraud prevention systems should be upgraded to require real-time ID checks (capable of stopping $60 billion in UI fraud outright) and eligibility verification prior to fund dispersal; all funding should be linked to performance.

Further, states should have to report data to the federal government from state administered benefit programs. This would aid efforts to truly crack down on fraud.

Congress needs to impose firm spending limits and enact a balanced budget amendment to restore constitutional governance and return to a limited government.

The government isn’t underfunded—it's wastefully stolen too much of what we have all worked hard to produce. Americans deserve a system that protects their hard-earned money, not one that squanders it.

This piece originally appeared in ArcaMax

Heritage Offers

Activate Your 2025 Membership

By activating your membership you'll become part of a committed group of fellow patriots who stand for America's Founding principles.

The Heritage Guide to the Constitution

Receive a clause-by-clause analysis of the Constitution with input from more than 100 scholars and legal experts.

The Heritage Founders' Almanac

Read biographical essays about our Founding Fathers like George Washington, Benjamin Franklin, and John Adams along with insightful analysis of primary sources.